Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brian Martinez's avatar

I started using ai narration for the short stories I post here on Substack every other Monday, which also feed to a podcast on Spotify, etc. I've used narrators on other projects in the past, and I still think it's better, but this way I'm creating audio versions of stories I otherwise wouldn't be. It makes my work more accessible, and hopefully opens up the audience a bit wider. This is one of those situations where it's not replacing anyone, because the alternative is that I simply wouldn't be able to afford to create an audio version of these stories. That's where I think ai really shines: making things that otherwise wouldn't exist possible.

Expand full comment
Jeccat's avatar

I feel like this is very much one of those "it's not the tool, it's the user" type things. Personally, I'm not against the technology, though my opinion is that the current AI stuff that's everywhere is having more harmful impact than good on a massive scale, and there's troublesome ethical problems with the way those AI tools have been put together and rolled out. It's why I loathe the term "AI art" because the current AI generators don't MAKE anything, they've been fed untold amounts of data that they then spit out like a collage (with no original additions) according to set patterns they've been taught. AI prompter is more accurate, as far as I'm concerned. And I don't have an issue with people who enjoy playing with those generators as a fun thing to do on the level of making/sharing memes or doing silly quizzes, but I think it's not right for people to claim that they've "made art" and try to sell it when all they did was type in some key words into a program that then spits out a (sometimes) unrecognisable smash up of millions of artists' works that have been scraped from the Internet without consent (and often with explicit requests to not take displayed art beyond saving a copy to enjoy for personal viewing pleasure).

Here's an article about the current state of the state of AI stuff in recent news that might be interesting: https://www.infinitescroll.us/p/weekly-scroll-the-internets-shower?r=2cx6re&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts